Permanent as a Tattoo: Israel, the Church, and Replacement Theology

How to process the tension between “replacement theology” and a plain reading of the Bible
4 min read

For the gifts and the call of God are irrevocable. -Romans 11:29, NET

On Levi’s forearm is a tattoo with the name of his wife, Lori, written in a smooth, stylish font. He got the tattoo on their honeymoon in Cancun, Mexico 20 years ago. Levi and Lori have been inseparable ever since.

But look closer at Levi’s forearm and you will notice another name – underneath Lori’s. It is hard to make it out, but it reads Jill, which was the name of Levi’s first girlfriend. He was young, in love, and couldn’t imagine their relationship ever coming to an end.

But unfortunately, after he got the tattoo, Jill took a liking to Levi’s best friend, Mike, and suddenly Levi found himself in the awkward position of having the tattoo, but not the girl. Just like that, the Jill tattoo became one of the most impulsive and silly things he had ever done.

The tattoo was a permanent reminder.

Once tattooed, always tattooed?

There’s a concept that comes up quite a bit in Christian conversations these days called “replacement theology.” If you’ve never heard of it, consider this your introduction. The discussion can get very complicated, but since this is just an introduction, we will try to keep it simple.

The upshot of the argument in replacement theology is that because of Israel’s rejection of Jesus a long time ago, God ended his dealings with them and replaced them with the church. Now the church, made up of all who have placed their trust in Jesus, is the main focus in God’s plan.

In replacement theology, all the promises that God made to Israel in the Old Testament are now applied to the church. Like this epic promise God made to Abraham, the patriarch of the nation of Israel and the first Jew:

I will make you into a great nation. I will bless you and make you famous, and you will be a blessing to others. I will bless those who bless you and curse those who treat you with contempt. All the families on earth will be blessed through you. Genesis 12:2-3

God promised Abraham that the entire world would be blessed through him. Of course, this was a prophetic reference to the fact that Jesus, the Son of God, would eventually come into the world by way of Israel, as a Jew. But replacement theology takes the liberty of reading promises like this in a way that superimposes the church in the place of Israel.

In other words, scratch out the name Israel and insert church in its place.

Yet, just like with Levi’s forearm, if we look closely and objectively into the New Testament, we will see the name of Israel still bleeding through so that it becomes impossible to completely forget her.

Yes, God is presently curating a living, breathing body of worshipers called the church, representing every tribe, tongue, and nation that will one day abide with Him in glory, but this does not mean that Israel has been scratched out.

Set aside for a time? Yes, for sure. But entirely scratched out? No.

One witness to this fact among many is found in Acts 28:20, where Paul curiously said to a Jewish audience that he was in chains because of “the hope of Israel.” By this phrase, Paul was obviously referring to Jesus. But how could Jesus be the hope of Israel if Israel had been replaced?

Even after Paul’s gospel witness had been rejected by so many Jewish people, he still referred to Jesus as the hope of Israel. In Paul’s mind, God had not given up on Israel. When he himself had grown exasperated by the obstinence of his Jewish kinsmen and had turned his missional focus to the Gentiles, still Paul referred to Jesus as the hope of Israel.

In Romans 9-11, Paul made it clear that God’s plan includes a unified future for both the church and Israel. Neither replaces the other. Using beautiful imagery, Paul explains that God will ultimately graft us both together into one tree. Though God’s plan for Israel and the Jews is on hiatus for now, it is not cancelled. Purely because of God’s loyal love, Israel will get another opportunity to receive her Messiah, and receive him she will.

In other words, it does not have to be either Israel or the church. On God’s big arm, there’s room for both of us.

It’s a new day with God. Run with it.

Leave a Reply